EU court says Dublin's passenger cap can limit airline slots
By Michal Zembol
Published .
On 15 October the Court of Justice ruled that the 32 million passenger limit in Dublin Airport's planning consents has to be counted when slots are allocated. A historic claim on a slot is not a guarantee if that legal capacity is smaller. The Irish High Court still has to apply the ruling.

The Court of Justice of the European Union ruled on 15 October that a passenger limit written into an airport's planning consent can be used when take-off and landing slots are allocated. In case C-857/24, daa and Others, the court looked at Dublin Airport. Development consents for the terminals, granted in 2007 and 2008, cap the airport at 32 million passengers a year. The court said that ceiling has to be reflected in the coordination parameters, the figures that state how much capacity is available for slots, where it restricts operations and the airport operator must comply with it. The age of the planning rule does not change that, and a later shift in the policy behind the rule does not change it either.
The Irish Aviation Authority sets those parameters for each season before the coordinator allocates slots. In 2024, the court said, forecasts from the airport operator indicated that the 32 million limit could be reached or passed. The authority then set seasonal passenger caps for flights to and from Dublin. The operator and a number of airlines challenged those decisions in the Irish High Court. The High Court asked Luxembourg whether the planning cap is a constraint the slot rules must count, and whether counting it can mean fewer slots, including for airlines that were already using them. RTE reported that Ryanair and the US group Airlines for America were among the challengers.
The court answered that the parameters must show, in operational terms, all the capacity that is actually available. Leaving a binding passenger cap out of that sum could allocate slots that could not legally be flown. Historic slots, the series an airline has used regularly and therefore has a prior claim on, exist so that timetables stay stable from one season to the next. The court said that claim still depends on the capacity being there. In exceptional cases, some series of historic slots, or part of a series, may not go back to the airline that would otherwise have had the first claim. A slot, the court added, is temporary. It is not a property right under the Charter of Fundamental Rights. The High Court now applies that reading to the Dublin cases. Any change to the schedule is for that court and, after it, for the coordinator.
How an airline keeps a slot
At a coordinated airport such as Dublin, a slot is permission to use the runway at a stated time. Airlines build a season out of a series: the same time, on the same day of the week, across the weeks of that season. Under the EU slot rules, Council Regulation 95/93, a series is at least five slots asked for in that pattern. An airline that has operated a series for at least 80 percent of the season has first claim on the same series in the next equivalent season. Coordinators call that historic precedence. The 80 percent test is the use-it-or-lose-it rule. It is there so that an airline cannot sit on a time it does not fly.
The judgment leaves that 80 percent test where it is. What it adds is the size of the pool. The pool has to fit the airport's legal capacity, as well as the number of movements the runways, stands and terminals could physically handle. A planning condition can therefore be tighter than the concrete. If the 32 million ceiling leaves fewer slots than the historic series added together, the coordinator can be short of slots to hand back. Where a reduction follows, it would be to a series or to part of a series, because the capacity figure is smaller. It would be separate from the penalty that applies when an airline flies less than 80 percent.
The cap itself is still a decision for Dublin
RTE reported that the Irish parliament passed a law this summer giving the minister for transport, Darragh O'Brien, power to lift the passenger cap, and that he has said he intends to use it. A process that may include an environmental assessment comes before that decision, and a change can still be taken to court. RTE also reported that the Irish Aviation Authority is not expected to allocate Dublin's winter 2027 slots until May 2027. If the cap has been removed or replaced before then, this judgment would not have to set that season's numbers.
The Department of Transport, in a statement reported by RTE, said the minister notes the ruling and will make no further comment while the High Court case continues. The Irish Aviation Authority said it will consider what the judgment means for those proceedings and for later decisions on slot capacity. Aer Lingus said the remaining statutory process should be completed so the cap can be amended, and that airlines, passengers and the Irish economy need the certainty. Ryanair called the ruling absurd at an airport that has opened a second runway. The airline said that runway takes Dublin's capacity to 60 million passengers a year, that traffic in 2026 will pass 36 million, and that the 32 million planning limit should be abolished. Those two capacity figures are Ryanair's. Friends of the Irish Environment said the government should manage passenger and flight numbers with climate targets and aircraft noise in mind.
